If you hit a wild deer and leave the scene in New York, you have not automatically committed a hit-and-run offense. New York Vehicle and Traffic Law § 601 identifies certain domestic animals, not wild deer. You may still need to notify the police, exchange information if another person or property is involved, and file a DMV crash report within 10 days if someone is injured or property damage to any one person, including yourself, exceeds $1,000. Your next steps depend on what happened during the collision.
For drivers in Buffalo, Williamsville, Amherst, Clarence, and nearby Western New York communities, understanding the difference between leaving a deer collision and failing to report a qualifying crash can help protect driving privileges.
Is It Illegal to Hit a Deer and Drive Away in New York?
A deer may dart into a road in Erie County or Niagara County before you have time to react. If you strike the animal and continue driving, that act alone does not establish a violation of the animal-reporting provision in Vehicle and Traffic Law § 601.
The result changes when the collision involves an injured person, another vehicle, damaged roadside property, or a reportable level of damage to your own vehicle. You should assess the accident safely rather than assume that leaving the scene ends your responsibilities.
What Does New York Law Say About Hitting an Animal?
Vehicle and Traffic Law § 601 requires drivers who strike and injure certain animals to stop, attempt to locate the owner or an appropriate officer, arrange reasonable attention, and promptly report the incident. The statute identifies:
- Horses
- Dogs
- Cats
- Animals classified as cattle
Wild deer do not appear in that list. The absence of deer from § 601 does not exempt drivers from other accident-related laws. If another person’s property is damaged or someone is injured, Vehicle and Traffic Law § 600 may impose separate stopping, identification, and reporting duties.
Read New York Vehicle and Traffic Law § 601
Learn about leaving the scene of an accident
Arthur Pressman focuses in the areas of DWI, traffic law and criminal defense.
When Must You Report a Deer Accident in New York?
Under Vehicle and Traffic Law § 605, drivers generally must submit Form MV-104 to the New York State DMV within 10 days when a crash results in:
- Injury or death to any person.
- More than $1,000 in damage to the property of any one person, including the driver.
- More than $1,000 in damage to another person’s vehicle or other property.
For example, if a deer damages your radiator, headlights, and bumper near Clarence and the damage to your vehicle exceeds $1,000, the DMV reporting requirement may apply even though no other car was involved.
Key reporting deadline: If a crash is reportable under § 605, file Form MV-104 within 10 days. Reporting the crash to your insurance company does not replace the DMV filing.
Failure to file a required MV-104 within the deadline is a misdemeanor. Your driver license and vehicle registration may also be suspended until the required report is filed. When someone is injured or killed, police notification duties apply independently of the later written DMV report.
Review the official DMV Form MV-104 and instructions
Read Vehicle and Traffic Law § 605
Do You Have to Call the Police After Hitting a Deer?
An immediate police call and a written DMV report are not the same requirement. You should call emergency services if a person is hurt, a dangerous obstruction remains in the roadway, or your vehicle creates an immediate risk. When the accident also damages another person’s property, comply with the stopping and identification requirements that apply to those circumstances.
Even if only your own vehicle is damaged, a police report may help document what happened. Contacting local authorities also allows an officer to address an injured deer or a roadway hazard. If you intend to seek possession of a deer carcass, a separate 24-hour reporting rule applies.
What Happens If You Leave Without Contacting the Police?
The consequences depend on the collision, not just on whether you drove away.
- Minor damage and no injuries: If no other person or property is involved and damage to your vehicle does not exceed the reporting threshold, an MV-104 may not be required.
- Damage above $1,000: You generally must file an MV-104 within 10 days, even if the deer ran away.
- Damage to someone else’s property: If your vehicle also hits another car, fence, or mailbox, you may have duties under § 600 to stop and provide identifying information.
- Injury to a person: Seek emergency help and comply with immediate notification and other statutory responsibilities.
A traffic citation may result from an additional violation, such as speeding or reckless driving, but striking a deer does not automatically prove such an offense.
Highly recommended Arthur pressman. I don’t live in Buffalo New York but while visiting my family there from Florida. I got pulled over while driving on a, suspended license in Florida. They arrested me and gave me a court date to appear in court and due to me living out of state I just could not afford to go back and forth to buffalo from Florida so that’s when I hired Arthur Pressman. He made sure to handle everything for me and kept me informed with what was going on. I received no points no penalties and the case was dropped. Thank you Arthur pressman your the best. Would definitely recommend you to family and friends.
Crystal B.
What Should You Do Immediately After Hitting a Deer?
Safety comes first. Take these steps according to the conditions at the scene:
- Move to a safe place if your vehicle can be driven without creating another hazard.
- Check for injuries and call emergency services if anyone needs immediate assistance.
- Keep your distance from the deer. An injured animal can move suddenly.
- Notify local law enforcement when there are injuries, roadway hazards, or other reasons for prompt reporting.
- Photograph visible damage and the surrounding road only when it is safe.
- Contact your insurer and follow the policy’s notice requirements.
- Complete Form MV-104 within 10 days if the crash meets New York’s reporting criteria.
Do not attempt to lift or transport an injured deer. If it remains in a traffic lane, tell the responding authority where it is located.
Can You Receive a Traffic Ticket for Hitting a Deer?
A deer collision alone does not establish that you violated a traffic law. Police may examine the circumstances to determine whether conduct such as speeding, distracted driving, driving while impaired, or reckless driving contributed to the accident.
If you receive a ticket, review the specific charge and evidence. A legal defense focuses on the alleged conduct and the applicable legal standard, rather than assuming that an animal collision proves a violation.
Review the firm’s traffic ticket defense information
Read about reckless driving defense
Related Videos
Will an Attorney Save Me Money?
Do I Need to Go to Court?
Could Leaving a Deer Accident Affect Your Driver License?
Yes. If the crash required a written DMV report and you failed to file it, your license or registration may be suspended until the reporting requirement is satisfied. Separate convictions arising from the accident can carry their own penalties.
If you receive a DMV notice or traffic ticket, record the response deadline, keep copies of the paperwork, and seek advice about the procedure that applies to your case.
Will Insurance Cover Damage From Hitting a Deer?
A collision directly involving a deer is generally considered an animal-related loss under comprehensive auto coverage, subject to the terms of your policy. Liability-only coverage typically does not pay for damage to your own vehicle. A later collision with another object may raise different coverage questions.
Your insurer may request photographs, repair estimates, and a description of the incident. Provide accurate information and preserve any supporting records. A police report may assist with documentation, but the insurance contract determines coverage.
Read New York State Department of Financial Services guidance on filing an auto claim
Can You Take Home a Deer You Hit With Your Vehicle?
New York Environmental Conservation Law § 11-0915 establishes a permit process for possession of a deer killed unintentionally in a vehicle collision. If your vehicle was damaged and you wish to possess the carcass, report the accident to an authorized officer within 24 hours. The officer must investigate and, if the legal conditions are met, issue a permit.
Do not take or transport the deer merely because you struck it. An officer may also authorize another person to take possession if the vehicle owner declines.
Read Environmental Conservation Law § 11-0915
Case Results
What If You Already Hit a Deer and Left the Scene?
You can still assess and address your reporting responsibilities. Write down the date, location, circumstances, and whether anyone was injured. Obtain a damage estimate and retain photographs, insurance correspondence, and any communications with authorities.
If the crash meets the DMV threshold and the 10-day period remains open, file Form MV-104 promptly. If you missed the deadline, seek legal guidance about the next steps and any notice or charge you received. Avoid guessing about facts you do not remember.
Frequently Asked Questions About Deer Accidents in New York
Do You Have to Call the Police After Hitting a Deer in New York?
Not every deer collision requires an immediate police call. Injuries, damage to another person’s property, and roadway hazards can create additional duties or reasons to contact police promptly. A reportable crash may also require a separate MV-104 filing.
Can You Be Charged With Hit-and-Run for Hitting a Deer?
Leaving after striking a wild deer does not, by itself, violate the animal-specific requirements in § 601. An offense may arise if the crash also involved a person, another person’s property, or other prohibited conduct.
Must You Report a Deer Collision If the Deer Runs Away?
The animal running away does not control the reporting requirement. A qualifying injury or more than $1,000 in damage to any one person’s property, including your own, generally requires an MV-104 report.
How Long Do You Have to Report a Deer Accident?
For a crash covered by § 605, the written DMV report is generally due within 10 days. Separate rules may require an earlier police notification, and a 24-hour report is required if you seek a deer carcass permit under § 11-0915.
Can You Keep a Deer After Hitting It?
Only through the lawful permit process. Under § 11-0915, report the qualifying collision within 24 hours and obtain authorization from the investigating officer.
Get Legal Guidance After a Deer Accident in Western New York
If you were cited after a deer collision, received a notice concerning an accident report, or have questions about leaving the scene, Arthur L. Pressman, Attorney at Law can review the circumstances and explain your options. The firm assists drivers in Buffalo, Williamsville, Amherst, Clarence, Cheektowaga, Niagara County, and nearby Western New York communities.
Contact the firm to request an initial consultation and discuss your situation.
This article provides general information, not legal advice. Your responsibilities and potential penalties depend on the facts and current law.
Arthur Pressman is who you want representing you in court. My son was pulled over and charged with 3 felonies and several misdemeanors. It was a terrible time, with my son arrested and taken to the holding center. I contacted Mr. Pressman, and it wasn’t long before the felonies were dropped as were some of the misdemeanors. My son is now getting the help he needs. Mr. Pressman is highly respected in the court system. I am very thankful for what he was able to do. We felt like we were living a nightmare but things turned around and got better because of him. He is very professional but also a genuine nice person . I highly recommend him.
J.N.O.