Yes, drivers charged with DWI in Western New York can challenge the chain of custody of a blood sample when questions arise about its collection, handling, storage, or testing. New York courts require reasonable assurances that the evidence is authentic and has remained materially unchanged. Missing records, labeling mistakes, or unexplained transfers may affect the reliability or admissibility of blood test results, although minor documentation gaps do not automatically make evidence inadmissible. Arthur L. Pressman, Attorney at Law, helps drivers in Buffalo and surrounding communities examine blood testing procedures and identify potential weaknesses in the prosecution’s evidence.
A blood alcohol test can become a central piece of evidence in a New York DWI prosecution. When laboratory results indicate that a driver had alcohol or drugs in their system, prosecutors may use those findings to support criminal charges. Yet the existence of a laboratory report does not automatically establish that every step of the testing process was reliable.
If you were arrested for DWI in Buffalo, Amherst, Cheektowaga, Williamsville, Niagara Falls, or another Western New York community, you may have questions about how your blood sample was handled. Understanding the chain of custody can help you recognize why the documentation surrounding a blood test matters.
What Is the Chain of Custody in a New York DWI Case?
The chain of custody is the documented history of physical evidence from its initial collection until its presentation in court.
In a DWI case involving blood testing, that history typically begins when a medical professional draws the sample and continues through its transportation, storage, laboratory analysis, and preservation.
The prosecution must establish that the blood tested was connected to the correct individual and remained in a condition suitable for reliable analysis.
Several steps may be documented:
- The identity of the person collecting the blood sample
- The date, time, and location of collection
- The labeling and sealing of collection tubes
- The individuals responsible for transferring the sample
- The storage conditions before laboratory testing
- The laboratory receipt and analysis of the evidence
- Any subsequent transfer or storage of the remaining sample
These records help establish whether the sample analyzed by the laboratory was the same sample collected from the accused driver.
Why Does Blood Sample Handling Matter?
Blood evidence differs from a photograph or a police officer’s written observations. It is biological material that requires appropriate collection, identification, preservation, and testing.
A sample can pass through several people’s hands before reaching a laboratory. Each transfer creates an opportunity for a documentation problem or handling mistake.
Consider a hypothetical driver arrested in Amherst. A qualified medical professional draws blood at a hospital, and an officer takes custody of the collection kit. The sample later reaches a laboratory, where technicians analyze its alcohol concentration.
If the paperwork leaves a significant period of custody unexplained, the defense may question whether the evidence remained secure.
The issue is not limited to whether someone intentionally interfered with the sample. The question is whether the prosecution can establish its identity and unchanged condition with sufficient reliability.
Related Videos
Choosing a DWI Lawyer
Cost of a DWI Attorney
Understand the charge
Our Buffalo DWI lawyer explains DWI, DWAI, aggravated DWI, and the possible penalties.
Protect your ability to drive
A Buffalo DWI lawyer can review the court and DMV issues in your case. Read about hardship-license eligibility and underage drinking penalties.
Discuss your next step
Speak with a Buffalo DWI lawyer about the stop, testing, and available defenses. Call (716) 517-4250 for a free consultation.
What Types of Chain of Custody Problems Can Be Challenged?
Several potential problems may justify closer examination during a Western New York DWI defense.
Missing or Incomplete Documentation
Evidence logs may contain missing signatures, incomplete transfer information, or inconsistencies between collection and laboratory records.
A missing signature alone does not establish that a sample was compromised. Multiple unexplained discrepancies may raise more serious questions.
Incorrect Sample Labels
Blood collection tubes generally require identifying information that connects them to the correct person.
A mismatch involving a name, identification number, or collection date may create uncertainty about the evidence.
The significance depends on whether other reliable records resolve the discrepancy.
Broken or Questionable Evidence Seals
Collection kits often incorporate tamper-evident seals intended to indicate whether a container has been opened.
An unexplained broken seal, inconsistent sealing records, or evidence of leakage could justify examining whether the sample remained in its original condition.
Improper Storage or Transportation
Blood samples must be handled in ways that preserve their suitability for testing.
A defense attorney may review storage temperatures, transportation delays, collection tube contents, and laboratory protocols when those details are relevant to the reliability of the analysis.
These concerns require case-specific evaluation. A storage delay or procedural departure does not necessarily prove that the reported blood alcohol concentration was inaccurate.
I was advised by a mutual acquaintance to contact Mr. Pressman following my DWI that I received on December 28, 2015. This was the best advice that I could have been given. He was available immediately to speak with. I was put at ease after speaking with him. It was my first DWI and I had no idea what to expect. It was an isolated case of making a very foolish decision to drive. I had so much anxiety and fear of the unknown. Throughout my whole case Mr. Pressman was very reassuring and kept a positive attitude about what my outcome was going to be. He was available several times when I had random questions and never made me feel like an inconvenience. He was right! My case ended up being reduced to a violation from a misdemeanor and now I can finally begin to have my life back to normal. It was a hard lesson to learn but with the right attorney by your side the transition will be easier.
Anita D.
Key point: A missing signature or transfer record does not automatically exclude a blood test. The court assesses whether the evidence is sufficiently identified and substantially unchanged.
Does a Broken Chain of Custody Automatically Dismiss a DWI Charge?
No. An incomplete chain of custody does not automatically require dismissal of a DWI charge.
New York courts distinguish between defects that prevent evidence from being authenticated and lesser gaps that affect how much weight the evidence deserves.
In People v. Julian, 41 N.Y.2d 340 (1977), the New York Court of Appeals addressed the foundational requirements for physical evidence. Courts may accept evidence despite certain gaps when the circumstances provide reasonable assurances of its identity and unchanged condition.
This distinction matters because a judge may admit a blood test while permitting the defense to question its reliability at trial.
A substantial, unexplained problem that undermines authentication may support an objection to admissibility. A smaller discrepancy may instead provide grounds for cross-examination.
Even if the blood results are excluded, prosecutors may attempt to establish intoxication through other admissible evidence, including driving behavior, officer observations, or field sobriety testing.
For drivers seeking information about these charges, the firm Buffalo DWI defense page explains the broader legal issues:
https://www.arthurpressmanlaw.com/criminal-defense/dwi/
How Does New York Law Regulate DWI Blood Testing?
New York Vehicle and Traffic Law Section 1194 establishes procedures governing chemical testing in impaired-driving investigations.
The statute addresses circumstances in which police may request chemical tests, certain testing authorizations, and qualifications for individuals who draw blood at an officer’s request.
Under Section 1194(4), specified medical professionals may collect blood for law enforcement purposes. Other listed personnel may qualify when statutory conditions are satisfied.
Section 1194 also includes a two-hour testing framework in specified circumstances. Its application depends on the facts, the legal authority for collection, and the relevant statutory provisions.
Not every blood sample obtained during a DWI investigation falls under identical requirements. Blood collected for medical treatment may present different legal questions from blood drawn at police direction.
A defense attorney must determine which rules govern the particular sample rather than assuming that every blood draw is subject to the same requirements.
How Can a Buffalo DWI Attorney Investigate the Blood Sample?
An attorney evaluating blood evidence may seek discovery materials that reveal how the sample was collected, transported, stored, and analyzed.
New York Criminal Procedure Law Article 245 generally governs prosecution disclosure obligations in criminal cases, subject to applicable limitations and procedures.
Relevant evidence may include collection records, laboratory reports, transfer documentation, testing protocols, and information concerning individuals who handled the sample.
The review may focus on questions such as:
- Who collected the blood, and were they authorized to perform the procedure?
- Do the collection and laboratory records identify the same sample?
- Are the seals, labels, and recorded transfer times consistent?
- Were appropriate collection materials and testing procedures used?
- Does laboratory documentation reveal any irregularities affecting reliability?
Where appropriate, defense counsel may consult a qualified forensic expert to evaluate technical questions involving collection procedures, sample preservation, or laboratory analysis.
The investigation may reveal a genuine evidentiary issue, or it may establish that the sample was properly handled. The strength of a chain of custody defense depends on the actual records.
Can Blood Test Evidence Be Challenged Before Trial?
Potentially. A defense attorney may raise appropriate evidentiary objections or seek a court determination concerning the admissibility of blood testing evidence.
The procedural approach depends on the particular concern.
A challenge involving an unlawful search or seizure may support a suppression motion. A chain of custody objection instead questions whether the prosecution has established an adequate evidentiary foundation for the particular blood sample. The court may address that question before or during trial.
The arguments are legally distinct, even when they concern the same blood sample.
A defense attorney can also examine the basis for the traffic stop, arrest, and chemical testing request.
For related defense considerations, see:
https://www.arthurpressmanlaw.com/criminal-defense/
Case Results
What Happens if Blood Evidence Is Excluded?
Exclusion of blood evidence can significantly change a DWI case, particularly when the prosecution relies heavily on a specific blood alcohol concentration.
Under Vehicle and Traffic Law Section 1192(2), driving with a blood alcohol concentration of 0.08 percent or higher can support a per se DWI charge. Section 1192(2-a) addresses certain aggravated DWI allegations, including a blood alcohol concentration of 0.18 percent or higher.
Removing the blood test may weaken the evidence supporting a concentration-based allegation.
Yet prosecutors may still pursue other charges when sufficient independent evidence exists. New York common-law intoxication provision, Section 1192(3), does not require proof of a particular numerical blood alcohol concentration.
An evidentiary ruling excluding a blood test does not, by itself, resolve every charge.
For the possible consequences of a conviction, review:
https://www.arthurpressmanlaw.com/criminal-defense/dwi-penalties/
What Should You Do After a DWI Arrest Involving Blood Testing?
If you face a DWI allegation involving a blood sample, taking organized steps early can help your attorney investigate the evidence.
Preserve your arrest paperwork, appearance notices, and any medical documents in your possession. Record what you remember about the blood draw, including its location, approximate time, and people present.
Avoid contacting laboratory employees or attempting to obtain evidence through informal means. Your attorney can identify appropriate procedures for requesting records.
You should also keep track of every court appearance and any separate DMV proceedings. Criminal charges and administrative licensing matters can involve different requirements.
Prompt legal advice may help protect your ability to identify available evidence and meet applicable procedural deadlines.
Frequently Asked Questions About DWI Blood Sample Evidence
Can a hospital blood sample be challenged?
Yes. Hospital blood evidence can raise questions about identification, collection, handling, and laboratory reliability. The legal rules governing access to medical records and police-directed testing may differ according to how the sample was obtained.
Can an incorrect date on a blood sample label invalidate the test?
An incorrect date can justify investigation, but it does not automatically invalidate the results. The court may consider whether surrounding documentation reliably establishes the sample’s identity.
Can a DWI attorney challenge the laboratory findings?
Yes. Depending on the available evidence, an attorney may examine laboratory methods, testing records, sample preservation, and the qualifications of personnel involved in the analysis.
Does every chain of custody challenge require a forensic expert?
No. Some disputes primarily involve missing records or conflicting testimony. Technical questions about biological preservation and laboratory methods may benefit from expert review.
Speak With a Western New York DWI Defense Attorney
If blood testing plays a role in your DWI case, you can seek a careful evaluation of the evidence and the procedures used to obtain it.
Arthur L. Pressman, Attorney at Law, brings decades of criminal defense experience and extensive knowledge of local courts to individuals facing DWI allegations in Buffalo, Williamsville, Amherst, Cheektowaga, Niagara Falls, and nearby areas throughout Western New York.
The firm can review the circumstances of your arrest, examine available chemical testing records, and explain whether a chain of custody challenge may be appropriate.
To request a consultation and discuss your situation, contact the firm:
https://www.arthurpressmanlaw.com/contact-us/
This article is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Consult an attorney about your specific situation.